TBI Brandon Winneshiek Native American Veteran

Botched TBI Exams Blocked Native American Veteran From VA Benefits And Health Care

An investigative journalist exposed another case of VA screwing a Native American veteran out of benefits, this time disability benefits for traumatic brain injury.

Marine veteran Brandon Winneshiek of the Ho Chunk tribe in Wisconsin was repeatedly injured by Improvised Explosive Device (IED) bomb blasts in Ramadi.

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and stay up to date.

While on foot patrol, the blast from two IEDs knocked him off his feet. “And next thing I know, I’m picking myself up off the road, looking to make sure I had both arms and both legs,” he said while wiping away a tear.

“Next thing you know – boom!” Brandon says, throwing his hands in the air as he describes a bomb placed in the stairway of a building his unit was using as a listening and observation post. “All I remember is getting up off the ground. I had been thrown across the room. My ears were ringing. I remember seeing stars and just confusion.”

KARE 11 investigative journalist AJ Lagoe highlighted Winneshiek’s experience this week in follow up to the 2015 scandal exposing VA’s longtime use of unqualified doctors and nurses to (mis)diagnose traumatic brain injury.

RELATED: VA OIG Finally Releases TBI Report On Disability Scandal

VA’s Large TBI Unqualified Doctor Scandal

I worked closely with KARE 11 to help expose the scope and impact of the scandal on veterans desperately fighting for disability benefits. Former VA Secretary Robert McDonald issued an equitable relief policy as a result to help nearly 25,000 veterans impacted by the malfeasance.

Earlier this week, I wrote about another instance where VA was caught blocking another Native American veteran from emergency healthcare for a kidney transplant. The excuse there was biased testing VA provided and then cited as the basis to deny an expensive kidney transplant.

RELATED: Tribal Advisory Committee Holds First Meeting

VA TBI Diagnosis Roadblocks

In this newest story, the Marine veteran needing TBI benefits repeatedly ran into roadblocks when fighting for compensation benefits for his brain injury residuals.

He was first seen at the Compensation clinic at Minneapolis VA Medical Center in 2012 for a TBI diagnosis for compensation benefits.

The doctor there concluded the veteran lacked a TBI. But, that doctor was one of many doctors and nurses conducting TBI examinations who was unqualified to conduct the exams.

RELATED: VA Secretary Offers TBI Scandal Fix

As part of a massive equitable relief undertaking, then VA Secretary Robert McDonald issued a relief plan and notice to over 24,000 veterans potentially affected. These veterans would receive new exams and significant support from VA to be made whole if the deficient exam was material, meaning, if a proper exam resulted in a favorable outcome for the veteran.

VA later referred Winneshiek to the Tomah VA Medical Center in 2015.

There, the veteran was directed to a qualified doctor who used an inadequate psychological screening exam to assess the TBI.

The physician, Mary Jo Lanska, a neurologist. She conducted a Mini-Mental State Exam (MMSE). She concluded the veteran did not have a TBI.

A Gundersen Health System neuropsychologist, Dr. Justin Otis, told KARE 11 news that the MMSE exam is generally used to assess elderly patients for dementia.

“Are these brief screening tools adequate to diagnose traumatic brain injury?” asked KARE 11’s A.J. Lagoe.

“They are not,” Dr. Otis replied. “It’s not meant to be a diagnostic tool. It’s not sensitive or specific for traumatic brain injury.”

Winneshiek continued to seek benefits from VA for the TBI but kept getting denied. He was not only denied compensation but also healthcare for the condition.

The Tomah VAMC team later referred Winneshiek back to Lanska in 2020 who denied a consult for TBI healthcare services citing her previous inadequate screening that concluded the veteran did not have a TBI.

Private Sector Fixes Botched TBI Diagnosis

The veteran eventually had to pursue care outside VA after the multiple refusals to help. He was then diagnosed with his TBI by Dr. Otis in perhaps an example of why allowing veterans to seek private care instead of VA mandated care is a worthwhile policy consideration.

Winneshiek was able to use the private assessments by Gundersen to win his benefits for TBI. And, predicably, while VA did grant TBI benefits, it refused to backdate the award.

How many other veterans were affected by the sham procedures employed by VA over the years that blocked veterans from benefits?

Probably countless, or at least VA would have us believe the number cannot be tallied.

Source: https://www.kare11.com/article/news/investigations/kare-11-investigates-broken-promises-unqualified-doctors-inadequate-tests-veterans/89-766d85fb-7c92-4b52-b031-ee73f5ec0105

Similar Posts


  1. Veterans who have incurred a TBI are more than twice at risk for Suicide.

    Good info from the VA’s VISN 19.


    One of our local disabled Veterans was denied VA Care for a TBI that was incurred as a result of a workplace injury. the reason for denial of care ws that it was part of a Workmans Comp Claim.

  2. I am currently appealing a a C&P decision due to my filing a claim for a service connected TBI from an inservice auto accident. this was a head on collision that occurred in the line of duty and I incurred multiple head traumas in addition to a fractured femur and fractured dislocated hip.

    My family noticed some changes in my demeanor when I returned home, but I like others have been able to compensate for this.

    My claim was that service connection be established for TBI and that I be compensated at 0%. My rationale requesting to establish service connection was for multiple reasons.

    the results of one TBI may not show up until late in life in the form of Alzheimers and the effects of multiple TBI or head injuries are cumulative.

    anxiety, depression, mood disorders, sleep disturbances/apnea even hypertension have all been shown to be linked to TBI. I have many of these conditions

    While the VA does have a TBI registry, it does not cover older Vets like me.
    I informed the examiner other head injuries I had experienced which required visits to the ER. he examiner opine in writing that I did incur a TBI as a result of that in service auto accident but then reduced this to a head injury in the same examination report.

    C&P denied my claim for service connection even though I requested 0% compensation.

    There is a lot of information with regards to the cumulative effects of head injuries/TBI as well as their relationship to other medical conditions.

    I am appealing the C&P decision. Establishing service connection for TBI, which the VA examiner admitted I did incur, as a result of my service, is my TBI registry with the VA.

    Hope this info is of use to some of you.

  3. I had two botched VA TBI exams before a third finally supported my claim.
    (Whole process took NINE years!)
    First was a 5 minute one by an internist.
    Second was by a psychiatrist who got me mixed up with another examinee in her report to the VA.
    Bottom line: always get a copy of your C-File. You may have your eyes opened.
    (Second bottom line: never give up!)

  4. I can unequivocally state by fact and with physical evidence that the issue of unqualified, under – qualified Doctors, nurses and technicians is HUGE.
    The other and more deceitful of the VA, is that the Main Offices are still to this day instructing ( threatening dismissal black balling) New Doctors,Nurses, technicians TO NOT ASSIST THE VETERANS, THEIR FAMILIES OR REPRESENTATIVES in gathering evidence, to help support claims for s/c benefits. This being done in clear violation Section 5103 38 U.S.C.

    1. I’m hear to say this just happened to me on my last pcp visit to the Deltona, Fl VA clinic. I asked for certain medical procedures or other things to be done. Nothing happened.
      Now my next appointment is in one year January 2022!
      These so-called professionals only care about their own interests!

  5. I’m pretty sure there are plenty of unqualified healthcare people (I refuse to say “professionals”!) working at every VA facility!
    Just yesterday, the so-called doctor said my kidneys were operating at the same level as they were 7 months ago. That’s a bald faced lie. They’re now operating 4 points less than before. They were at 50%. Now they’re at 46%.
    No explanation was given.
    There’s so much B.S. going on now. It’s hard to see the TRUTH!

Comments are closed.