MMQB: GI Bill, VA Voc Rehab, Disability Pay, How to Handle a Benefits Cut
If you’ve been awake for the past week, at any point you would have seen a lawmaker chaos in Washington, D.C. SNL captured it well on Saturday, but should’ve included more Democrats in the skit.
Since Tuesday, Veterans have been torn down party lines, but they are also waking up to a bigger reality: both parties have a hand in this mess. We have not had a full budget pass through Congress for three years. Instead, our politicians have chosen to raise the debt ceiling.
On the Right, Republicans have proposed bills that were voted down to fund VA. However, using a little slight of hand, those proposed bills would have cut $6 billion from VA’s budget. Nice try guys.
On the left, Democrats refuse to budge on anything. They claim Republicans need to fund everything. However, they did fund the military somewhat and some other things relating to immigration.
Most recently, HJ 72: Veterans Benefits Continuing Appropriations Resolution, 2014 has passed the House. Now we are waiting for the Democrat controlled Senate.
A bigger issue for many is the threat Democrats and the President have made against disability pay, GI Bill money, and Vocational Rehabilitation funding.
In a last minute reversal, the Department of Veterans Affairs notified veterans that their disability pay may be at risk. That conversation has now spread to include the GI Bill, VA Vocational Rehabilitation and other educational benefits.
I will touch on this and more below.
Hi and welcome to another edition of Monday Morning Quarterback, for veterans. I am your host, Benjamin Krause. This is where I let me hair down and call ‘em like I see ‘em.
Here’s the drill. I brew some coffee. Then I drink it and write as much as I can in the morning on the issues you want me to talk about.
Today, we will be covering the following:
- Getting ready for a disability pay cut
- 60 Minutes goes after Disability Insurance with Senator Tom Coburn
- National Park fiasco
- SNL spoofs House Republican majority (video at bottom)
Getting ready for a benefits pay cut
Before I jump into what I think is going on, I wanted to write about what I think veterans may want to do to prepare – since we can never know exactly what will happen.
For veterans who will be negatively impacted, implement a “plan for the worst, hope for the best” approach. Here are some suggestions to avoid homelessness should the checks stop flowing:
- Take out a credit card if you can
- Call creditors / landlords to alert them about the potential cut
- Call utility companies to alert them about the potential cut
- Call your university financial aid office to request an emergency scholarship
- Keep enough cash on hand to live for one month
- Keep enough food on hand to live for one month
- Call family members or friends who may be able to help
- Identify available resources for food and shelter
- Identify VA resources that could be available, veterans centers
The sad fact here is that we cannot rely on VA to be straight with us because it is playing politics based on the political decisionmakers the Executive has control over in every Administration.
This means we need to have a back up plan in case the worst does happen. Let’s hope this is all puffery, and that the partisanship will cease sooner than later.
What I think is going on
First of all, let me just say that Veterans Affairs and the President are playing politics with our benefits. Democrats in the Senate are also along for the ride. Meanwhile, Republicans are looking for ways to cut the VA budget. What a crock!
For those of you who are hardcore partisan, I say this as an Independent Voter who voted for Obama and Bush – minds blown, I know – Independent Voters do exist, and we are saddened that we do not have better options when it comes to selecting leaders for this great nation.
I also say this as the guy who told the Democrats what they needed to do to win the veteran vote – just do the right thing for veterans. One year later they score a big FAIL. Here is a link to the video: https://bit.ly/11ChtBi
So, please hold off on calling me a Repiglican or a Demoqwack for daring to provide commentary on the President or Congress. I call strikes strikes and balls balls.
I have a hunch this issue because of who is saying that our benefits are at risk and how they are saying it. Let me explain.
When you read all the press releases and news stories about our benefits being cut, they all say about the same thing. At risk are our GI Bill, VA Pension (not the same as retirement) VA Education Benefits, and disability pay, supposedly.
The news releases generally say something like this, “[T]he VA announced that if the shutdown lasts longer than two to three weeks, it might not have enough cash on hand to pay benefits in November.” (Providence Journal quoting IAVA)
Notice that none of the statements say that benefits will stop on October 16, or November 1. They instead say, “might not have enough cash…” Ridiculous, and here is why.
The public relations company that came up with this tactic, basically a legal hedge, assumed we veterans and the public at large would falsely assume: 1) Veterans Affairs is like us; 2) That the agency would not exactly know how much cash on hand it had; and, 3) As such, the agency would not know with any certainty whether or not the funds would stop.
There is something highly insincere about what that statement says and what it assumes about the reading public.
Can it be true that a $150 billion agency does not own a calculator? VA does, after all, have multi billion dollar IT programs that do budgeting. Further, the agency has a real life CFO who must evaluate VA’s financial position at all times and report it to Congress.
Since VA does have advanced budgeting systems, I believe it is highly unlikely that VA does not know when the money will run out. Therefore, this claim about benefits running out must be a ruse. But for what?
I think we are being hoodwinked, but I am not sure what the end game is beyond pressuring veterans into pressuring Republicans. Perhaps that, in and of itself, is the end game.
Another possibility is that the Executive is reworking how veterans are paid, and in order to accomplish some feat through the Treasury, payments must go offline for some duration. Or, perhaps it is more of a psychological punishment tactic. I’m not sure but there are lots of possibilities.
Regardless of the reason, my point is that VA and the President are not being totally honest with what is going on. I guess it is possible that the money will run out. But, based on the statement above “might run out”, it also seems possible that VA DOES have enough money to keep the benefits checks flowing.
I’m pissed. The reason I am pissed is that Democrats, and VA, for at least 3 years have all said VA benefits would be safe if we had a shut down. I participated at the Veterans Roundtable in 2012 with Rep. Nancy Pelosi and Rep. Tim Walz. They said we were safe to all VSO’s and other parties.
This duplicity is further illustrated by VA’s most recent communications on the issue. On September 27, VA displayed on its website on PDF that said veterans disability paychecks would be fine. The day before the shutdown, VA reversed its position.
See for yourself:
For now, we don’t know the truth, exactly. So, plan for the worst, just to be safe. Hopefully some resolution will pass soon.
60 Minutes goes after Disability Insurance with Senator Tom Coburn (OK-R)
In what appears to be curious timing, 60 Minutes aired a piece highlighting Senator Tom Coburn’s war against Social Security Disability Insurance.
The gist of the piece is that 4 million people are defrauding the government, and that lawyers are getting rich helping this fraud.
This is curious timing because disability payments are now an issue for veterans due to the payment cut threat from Democrats. A viewing public largely uneducated about VA disability will lump veterans issues into the same pot as SSDI.
The net effect could be an erosion of the sympathy veterans normally receive on the subject.
In the interview, Coburn claimed that 33 percent of all claims are fraudulent. He did not provide any study or research to support his claim. He did, however, provide a couple anecdotal stories – so a couple stories out of 12 million recipients.
They conclude that attorneys are involved because it is lucrative. This is perhaps true with some chop shops that specialize in the field.
However, by and large, lawyers are not getting rich. Lawyers across the nation are making an upper middle class living while paying down $150,000 in student loan debt – just like doctors.
Coburn concludes the piece by repeating a veiled warning. Disability Insurance payouts will either need to be cut 25% by 2015 or there will need to be an increase in the payroll tax.
Watch it here:
National Park rangers shutting down private businesses
From the Washinton Times:
“The National Park Service has closed privately run marinas, restaurants and inns throughout the country and in some cases even posted guards to keep people from using them during the government shutdown, arguing that it doesn’t have the money, manpower or authority to let them operate.
“But the moves, which likely have thrown thousands of people out of work, are drawing scrutiny from Congress and don’t rest well with many voters who believe the administration is making the effects of the shutdown worse than necessary.
This comes back to what I said last week, that National Park closures defy common sense economics.
The fact is, it costs more to actively guard businesses and open air monuments than it does to just shut down by walking away.
Some readers have argued that, “At least the President is being fair.” But, being “fair” is nice when you have two children and you are the parent. It’s not the duty of the Executive to play parent, and that argument is premised on the assumption that his job is to be a daddy.
Further, someone made a decision about what would and would not be classified as essential. The decision was reached to shut down national parks even though they are revenue positive operations. Such a decision plainly defies common sense economics at a time when the country is collectively screaming for more revenue because it keeps the government from collecting revenue.
Therefore, I can only conclude that there is some other motive.
The only motive I can think of is that the Executive is trying to usurp the daddy role by being overtly paternalistic, and in so doing has decided to punish the nation by shutting down its parks.
Source: National Park rangers ordered to keep visitors out of privately run businesses
SNL Spoofs Boehner, Bachmann
I thought I would include this so that everyone knows I can rip on both parties equally.
Some of you may not like this kind of humor. As a warning, I was the kid at church camp who always got in trouble for telling “adult” jokes.
Anyway, in this video short, SNL depicts what Republicans are doing in DC during the shutdown set to the Miley Cyrus video. It’s pretty funny. Click on the triangle to watch.
Talk about double whammy. First I have to worry if my VA disability check will come at the end of the month so I can pay my mortgage and be able to have a roof to put over my daughter and my head. Then I also have to worry about what is going to happen if my VA post 9/11 GI bill funds don’t come through. No money to put food on the table and finish up my degree would be a really big setback! Irony is I choose a University overseas because of the free healthcare and they are part of the VA yellow ribbon program. I don’t qualify for any sort of public assistance overseas. Yikes. Get your act together Congress…and try living without your paycheck for a while!
Your critical thinking is exactly where my brain has been with watching and listening carefully, as this has all played-out! I too watched 60 Minutes Program last night and I found it to be totally another “convenient, timely, psychological propaganda attempt”, and what’s actually more of a fact here is that **MOST** Americans, educated or not, have absolutely no idea the HUGE difference between SSDI and SSI. The line is further blurred when it’s convenient for whomever is politically lumping the two all together just about the only “truth” of matter they will disclose when it’s *beneficial* to do so, which is that The State’s individually handle SSI, which is indeed part of a State’s and Federal Welfare Programs:
a) When a person whom is disabled but does not have the minimal required 10 years of solid work history and paying into Social Security in order to be “vested” with Social Security Disability, will then NOT receive SSDI (Social Security Disability Income), a more defining of the “I” in SSDI is the word “Insurance”, because that is exactly what it is and why one needs to be “Vested” in order to qualify, just as any Life Indemnity Insurance Policy is.
b) What a lot of Americans do not realize either is it’s NEVER Political Refugees, Immigrants whom have never worked or “deadbeat Americans” that receive SSDI,as Senator Coburn would have you believe. No, Political Refugees, other Immigrants, and all whom have not PAID INTO and SUFFICIENT TIME in Soc. Sec. Income Taxes, receive SSI, which by definition is Supplemental Income, part of THE Social Safety-net that is part of our Welfare System.
c) It’s actually incredibly difficult to be awarded SSDI. Senator Coburn never delineated between the two, and those huge law firms whom specialize in such in-fact can in NO WAY circumnavigate the basic requirement of needing to have a SOLID work history and as aforementioned, paying taxes INTO Soc Sec to be awarded SSDI if deemed Disabled by Social Security Disability Determination and it’s JUST as difficult to be awarded as VA Disability.
d) My own experience of while I was waiting on long hard road of VA Disability process, and I indeed had worked ALL my life from youngest age, paying into Soc Security before a long USAF career, it was suggested that I also apply for SSDI by an assigned case worker while in-patient hospital stay for literally plethora of chronic medical issues, and my 7th such in-patient stay within no less than 14 months!
e) While waiting on VA, and being denied THREE TIMES by Social Security, even though I had no “magic attorney”, doing all the work actually myself, to include my whole VA Claim, TWO YEARS went by. I was one week from actually being homeless, had been acquiring food from food banks, food banks BRINGING me food a lot of times due to fact my body just could not, NOT that I was not willing, again, as Senator Coburn-my-ass would have people believe. I was prodded to swallow my pride and apply for Public Housing, Food Stamps–all of which was incredibly humiliating because the VSO certainly **NEVER** gave me any such advice of how the hell to weather this storm of time and survive. It is and was educational because I know how many a Veteran become homeless because I saw from the inside perspective of just how little to no help nor care was given to my state of affairs, let alone very sanity.
f) Long story, but needed to state I probably was a rare case where my Dr.’s whom I still have–outside the VA System–are foremost researchers and have Vitae’s that make any VSO look like a Temp Service Worker…all my Dr.’s were scratching their heads because with Social Security Disability Insurance, very much like the VA (but neither Gov’t Agency EVER share records nor communicate–EVER), in application process and through all denials, YOUR OWN PRIVATE MEDICAL DR’s opinion and whom REALLY knows you, is NEVER considered until you have been denied THREE TIMES for SSDI and then ONLY an Administrative Judge appointed by Social Security will ONLY THEN look subjectively at the WHOLE picture.
I was awarded my due SSDI, then two more years later my VA 100% Disability, got myself OFF Public Housing, Food Stamps, and because I actually now have Medicare, I just continued to use my non-VA medical team and use Medicare Part D for my medications because if I used the VA, I would still have to use Medicare and yet wait 6 months for the VA to decide if they will pay as second order of payee and by that time I am in collections–a vicious circle and a disservice to we Veterans.
Yes, this is a long ass post, and I too believe we Veteran’s are being held hostage by both sides of aisle, with an extremist part of one Party that Veterans need to NOT FORGET that not that long ago, Michelle Bachmann from Minnesota thought we Veterans *had it too good on Disability* and actually sought to have our benefits reduced–fact!
I am not sorry I took up this much space but I was rather pissed after last evening’s 60 Minutes and what Senator Coburn DID NOT SAY. Half-truths, just as the wording Ben pointed-out with VA saying “…we MAY not have enough funds to pay Veterans…”, is nothing less than psychological propaganda and if my health would not literally bar this, I personally would run as an Independent Candidate but as it is, try to educate and enlighten from where I am and than The Lord for each day.
Please get out and vote and do not let these people undermine your will to keep on keeping on!
Ben, to be clear here, the HJ 72: Veterans Benefits Continuing Appropriations Resolution, 2014 bill which passed the House is ALSO THE SAME BILL that Veterans Affairs’ Chairman Bernard Sanders introduced last Monday – WITH $6 BILLION CUT from the VA’s budget. What happened is that the Republicans mirrored the Democrats proposal.
Something to think about. Bernie Sander’s legislation would have paid for my, yours, and the other veterans’ compensation and pension benefits PRIOR TO THE GOVERNMENT SHUTDOWN BY OBAMA. However, the Democratic-controlled Senate refuses to vote on Bernie Sander’s bill or the House’s version that would have paid our monthly disability compensation and pension.
Furthermore, Republican Congressman Jeff Miller, the Chairmain of the House Committee on Veterans Affairs, stated that HE WANTS TO FULLY FUND THE VA when he said:
“I ask the Senate majority leader and my friends in the Democratic leadership to unite. Take up the bill that the ranking member has already said that fully funds veterans on June 4. ”
The only politicians stalling on paying us veterans are Obama, Democrats, and RINOS. It is these three groups of politicians that are playing politics with our livelihoods!
Veterans are deliberately being targeted for a painful demonstration of what happens when a CINC-wannabe doesn’t get his way with a failed Obamacare program that is hurting veterans’ families and the poor middle-class of America.
Obama wants veterans to feel the pain! That is why we must vote politicians like him out of office in 2014!
In all due respect, the last thing we Veterans need is to become politically voracious amongst each other. Critical Thinking does not involve partaking in each glass of Kool-Aid served, regardless of one’s leaning politically one way or other.
At this point, I do not see how *any* Veteran could claim with a straight face that ANY Party or faction is really caring about those whom have served to preserve our freedoms and liberties.
We may not have agreed with any given “Peacekeeping Action” or “Wars” we have been part of, but we served regardless and such, I think we should stick together rather than become carnivorous amongst each other.
Give me facts, please. I am a high information voter. I need facts so that I can be persuaded one way or the other when it comes to vote.
As for the insinuation that providing facts is somehow indicative of being politically voracious against another veteran, well, that is plain wrong. As individuals, we need to use objective criteria to examine whether a politician’s statements or actions are truly for supporting veterans’ causes. The subjective spin coming out of Obama’s and Reid’s mouths is clearly evident of their manufactured deception.
However, all the facts I have provided demonstrate that the Establishment mentality of Obama, Democrats, and RINOS are the root cause of all the ills and evils being done against veterans in America.
Prove me wrong, please. Give me facts.
For those who have an account history with USAA in regards to their disability compensation payments deposited, they are offering the same 0% advance that the are giving to active duty members. At least USAA is trying to take care of veterans.
Comments are closed.