Why is the VA Scandal a Foreign Policy Issue?

6

140610 Foreign Policy Report

Benjamin KrauseForeign Policy Magazine circulated its newsletter yesterday with surprising coverage of the VA Scandal. In its National Security Daily Brief, Foreign Policy included a great variety of commentary on the VA scandal from a number of sources including DisabledVeterans.org:

Benjamin Krause, writing in a blog post on the DisabledVeterans.org Website: Obama “will need to address the apparent and embarrassing incompetence of his staff regarding its inability to properly vet candidates in [a] timely manner…The second, and most difficult, is that he will need to address the fact that being an executive at VA is a very unpopular career choice in the middle of a major scandal.”

This may lead some of you to ask the question, “Why is the VA Scandal and treatment of veterans a foreign policy issue?” The answer is simple. How America allows veterans to be treated directly impacts our ability to recruit from the top pool of candidates in this country. Americans fondly refer to this pool as “the best and the brightest” individuals our country has to offer. With no draft, these individuals will have the option to not serve, which impacts recruit quality. Let me explain.

 

VETERAN TREATMENT AND MILITARY RECRUIT QUALITY

For years, I have called the unmistakable crimes against veterans by the Department of Veterans Affairs a dubious attack against our national security. America’s ability to be militarily secure requires that our military be qualified and competent, which directly impacts the success of our foreign policy. That is the connection. My simple theory here is this: Our ability to recruit more quality soldiers is dependent on our positive treatment of veterans, because more individuals from the pool of “the best and the brightest” will sign up for military service.

Taking it a step further, “the best and the brightest” will not sign up for military service if they believe America will not honor its commitments to them on the battlefield and after military service. Keep in mind, these potential recruits are “the best and the brightest” meaning they will have numerous life and career options.

Today, there are many options that will allow Americans to have successful careers and be patriotic without serving in our Armed Forces. This makes sense to most people, but the media does not discuss the connection often enough. Since Foreign Policy touched on the topic yesterday, I thought it was an opportune time to address it here.

Let’s test out this dependency theory with a quick thought experiment.

Would you work for a dishonest employer who abandons other employees after they are harmed? Put another way, would you work for an employer if the work is dangerous, there is no guarantee of Workers’ Compensation, and there are no adequate health care facilities to treat you if you are injured? Oh, and let’s not forget to include that the pay will be low and you will be away from your family. People with options who are the best and the brightest would likely say, “No.”

 

HONEST TREATMENT OF VETERANS REQUIRED

Honorable and honest treatment of military members and veterans directly impacts this dependent relationship. When the two groups are treated well, Americans perceive military service as a good and trustworthy endeavor. I use the word ‘trustworthy’ because, in a perfect world, our recruits could rely on our country to honor its commitments after service if injured. In theory, if there is trust, there is a relative increase in recruit quality.

Today, we see the exact opposite reality, and the potential is there to diminish the quality of our Armed Forces and to harm our foreign policy as a result. There is no doubt that many amazing Americans are serving today. But, reports are on the rise of increased gang violence in the military along side increasing headlines exposing military prostitution indicate America needs to be concerned. According to a recent Marines report, there are growing concerns that troop quality may go down in the near term. The signs all indicate recruit quality is at risk in part due to an erosion of quality in the candidate pool.

In the days of such heroes as Major Malcolm Wheeler-Nicholson (WWI era Cavalry hero, foreign military expert, creator of what became DC Comics), the above behavior was unheard of at a time when America demanded greater accountability from its government leaders. The Major risked it all by exposing corruption in the Army by blowing the whistle in an article he published in the New York Times. He later survived an assassination attempt his family believes was orchestrated by the Army in response to his exposure of its corruption. The Major, a military hero turned journalist and comic book creator, believed that by exposing government corruption and then replacing it with honesty and common sense, that America would remain a beacon of hope for the world. Our current leaders should take note of his example.

 

DECADES OF VA SCANDALS ERODE NATIONAL SECURITY

However, for over four decades, veterans have been fighting tooth and nail for the benefits they were promised when they took the oath of military service. Disability benefits have long seemed out of reach due to some kind of backlog, endless denials, and an inappropriately adversarial Board of Veterans Appeals. Once disability was granted, the veteran then faces another battle. The veteran then fights for adequate and timely health care to help treat the condition the veteran previously fought to document as a disability.

This disgraceful treatment impacts our recruitment abilities. I will step out on a limb by pointing out that numerous patriotic families now discourage military service due to the dishonesty we see before us in this current VA scandal and similar scandals prior to it. For example, one friend’s grandfather, who was a WWII hero, suffered through numerous failed attempts at getting VA care and benefits and was still picking out Japanese shrapnel up to his death. When Uncle Sam came knocking for boys like his come Vietnam, he refused to allow his children to enlist under threat of moving to Canada. His fears were not only related to the trauma and risk of war, but that his boys would endure the same fight he fought as a disabled veteran.

This veteran is not alone, and through decades of failures, we have subverted our national security by failing to honor our commitments. Many more veteran families from the current wars will have the same reaction, in part, due to America’s dysfunctional and criminal treatment of veterans. Distrusting families like these will include those with children who fall into the “best and brightest” pool I mentioned above. They will not send their children to fight for a country that does not honor its commitments.

The connection here is clear.

An America that does not honor its commitments to its troops after service is an America that does not care about its foreign policy. We need to wake up, hold those criminals accountable who have harmed veterans for so long, and correct this disastrous path we have followed for decades. The safety of our children’s, children’s, children depend on it.

#####

Voc Rehab Survival GuideBenjamin Krause is an award winning investigative reporter, Veterans Benefits Law attorney, and disabled veteran of the US Air Force, where he served in its Special Operations Command. He attended Northwestern University and  the University of Minnesota Law School using VA Vocational Rehabilitation. While in law school, Benjamin won his decade-long fight for full disability benefits and now helps others do the same with this website and his guide, the Voc Rehab Survival Guide for Veterans. Since its first publication in 2011, the guide has helped the veteran community receive millions in untapped benefits through the VA Chapter 31 Vocational Rehabilitation & Employment program. Connect with Benjamin on  Google+,  Twitter,  Facebook and LinkedIn.

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Dennis
Dennis

The only thing that’s going to help solve anything is to allow veterans more access to the legal system so that veterans can sue the VA for incompetence, malfeasance, neglect, etc. The list goes on! The way I see it, this current scandal at the VA is only the tip of the iceberg because there’s a whole entire range of other issues at the VA that nobody in the public is even aware of yet. The American public, by and large are apathetic about veterans anyway.

Curtis Cotton
Curtis Cotton

Dennis, Good luck finding a Lawyer. “I” Believe, The V.A. Is Immune to Lawsuits.
They could operate on you and leave All their Surgical “Tools” inside you, throw in all the gause & Gloves in for good measure, Sew you up to die with a staph Infection. AND It would take a Generation to get a Lawyer and Literally “AN Act of Congress” To get it before a Judge or even get it filed in a Court.
I`m of course not speaking from experience, I`m not a Lawyer, and Am more than likely wrong, But, I don`t “Think” you can sue the V.A. So, We are taking our lives into our own hands, By going there for treatment. If what i used earlier Actually Happened Someone “Might” Get in trouble, But, I seriously Doubt Your Family would ever get anything.for your pain & suffering. (My guess, not backed by any facts) But, It IS a SAD point to ponder.

American Veteran
American Veteran

Well said, Ben.

J. Edward ernon jr.
J. Edward ernon jr.

YOU HAVE A WAY WITH “SIMPLICITY”. I TRIED TO SAY THE EXACT SAME THING, BUT I TRIED USING “ELITIST” TERMS(OOPS).
THANK GOD FOR YOUR “PEOPLE” SENSITIVE WORDS.

r. dangerfield
r. dangerfield

I’m from the Vietman era ’67-’70 when there was a draft in effect. All of the veterans I have met don’t even want to use the VA health care system because it totally sucks for every little thing you do. I use it for certain things like meds or imaging – always have some sort of a problem with them doing something incorrect and having to do it over again. That’s where all the time goes with them. Throughout the decades, I have heard really bad stories about everything that goes on at every facility. People having to quit going there anymore because it was too much crapola. I believe it is dangerous to use them and I believe, without a doubt, that they want to hurt us and kill us. Yes the government wants to hurt us and kill us. I belive this pile of sxxx will not change because of this recent scandal. I belive this scandal will hurt the few good people that work there more than anyone else, in fact.
If you look at the technology developments in land and sea armed forces, you will notice the direction of modern warfare going towards using less people on ships and less human means on land- ie. robots that can do more than a human and faster, and new Zumwalt destroyers that use half the crew as older destroyers. This is the beginning of having to deal with less humans afterwards and less going to the VA, so they think.
The VA can not and will never be able to handle more and more veterans like they are so poorly doing now. Nobody likes the VA or the VAHS. It’s unworkable.

Dennis
Dennis

I am one veteran who would be more than willing to share some of my experiences with any young person who is considering joining the military, and inform them about the dangers of military service and should he/she get injured or disabled while in the military he faces a lifetime of abuse and neglect at the hands of the people who are supposed to care for him. The military and VA aren’t like the private sector where a person has workman’s comp. and has access to lawyers, etc., etc. Here, all you have is VA. And guess what? You’re not allowed to sue them!